5 of 5 seats affirm compliance; no seat finds a violation
Opus 5 (Anthropic)compliesread reasoning
This is a mechanical refactor: eight shared .mjs modules move from scripts/lib/ to src/lib/ with 27 import paths and doc references re-pointed, sixteen superseded protocol files move under protocols/archive/, and one behavioural change makes the review-note label a separate step after issue creation with a warning printed if it fails. No content/ records, citations, locators, assessments, or provenance stamps are touched, and the citation tooling found no identifiers in added content lines. AGENTS.md is not edited. None of the §3.15 checks is loosened: the panel's fail-closed 'unsure' handling, the vendor seat table, the citation checker, and the merge rate limit are all the same code at new paths; the review-note change strengthens rather than dodges the lone-objection mechanism by making label failure loud and giving a title-based fallback queue (documented in MAINTENANCE.md). The one thing I would want confirmed is that loadProtocol, which the diff says reads only the top level, can still resolve a promptVersion pointing at an archived version, but the archived text remains in git either way, so provenance for past runs is not lost. The DECISIONS.md entry is stamped with date and channel as the constitution's founder-direction clause allows.
GPT-5.6 Sol (OpenAI)compliescites §3.14, §3.15read reasoning
The eight shared modules and sixteen protocols are pure renames, with imports and documentation updated consistently and no visible change to citation, panel, or provenance-checking logic. Superseded protocol text remains versioned under `protocols/archive/`, while current loading is explicitly limited to top-level protocols, preserving historical prompt provenance without presenting old protocols as current. The review-note change still creates the constitutionally required public issue, then attempts to apply the queue label; failure is reported loudly and the deterministic title supplies a documented fallback search rather than silently losing the objection. No `AGENTS.md` or content records are changed, and no citation identifiers are added.
Gemini 3.8 Flash (Google)compliesread reasoning
The pull request performs a clean refactor moving shared library files from scripts/lib/ to src/lib/ and updating import paths across the codebase without altering module behavior. Sixteen superseded prompt protocols are archived under protocols/archive/ with no text modified, preserving historical reproducibility. The review note helper script is updated to reliably apply the review-note label via a follow-up edit step. No content files or epistemic assertions are modified, AGENTS.md is untouched, and no constitutional checks under §3.15 are weakened.
Grok 4.5 (xAI)compliesread reasoning
The diff is a pure structural refactor: eight library modules rename from scripts/lib/ to src/lib/ with import-path updates only (100% similarity), sixteen superseded protocol files move to protocols/archive/ without content change, and review-notes.mjs applies the review-note label as a separate post-create step with absence reported. No AGENTS.md edit, no content/ ledger or citation changes, no check-weakening, and no run records. Docs and DECISIONS.md only record the founder-directed move and preserve promptVersion provenance for archived protocols.
GLM 5.3 Flash (Z.ai, via Venice)compliescites §3.15, §3.14, §3.7, §3.8read reasoning
This is a mechanical refactoring PR with no content/ additions (citation verification confirms zero citation identifiers added), so §3.1–§3.13 are not engaged. The eight library modules move with 100% similarity (pure renames), and the citation checker, seat logic, and fail-closed arbiter-core are re-pointed, not altered — no §3.15 check is loosened or dodged; the panel-packet comment in scripts/arbiter.mjs still states that AGENTS.md amendment is reserved to the founder and that failed seats count as explicit `unsure` votes. Archiving sixteen superseded protocol versions preserves every recorded run's traceability because promptVersion names its file and the text stays in the tree, which honors §3.14's revision-history requirement rather than eroding it. The review-notes.mjs change actually strengthens the review-note queue (§3.15's lone-objection mechanism): the label is now applied as a verified step with its absence reported aloud, fixing the silent failure where notes #217 and #220 were undiscoverable. Docs updates (AUTOMATION, MAINTENANCE, INTEGRATIONS, a decisions entry stamped with date and channel) accurately describe the change; the DECISIONS entry attributes the direction to the founder in session, which is a recorded operating direction, not an AI-record-as-human-record misattribution, and no AGENTS.md edit appears in the diff.
judged against constitution ce771a77f7 · panel-v3 · verbatim record · pull request