5 of 5 seats affirm compliance; no seat finds a violation
Opus 5 (Anthropic)compliesread reasoning
The change is a narrow code fix to `narrowLocator` plus tests plus an append-only DECISIONS.md entry; AGENTS.md is untouched and no content/ records or citations are added (verification found no identifiers). I traced the new implementation against every assertion in the test file: parenthetical stripping, place-chunk selection, and rest-joining all yield the expected strings for the pre-existing cases and the four new ones, including the page-24 case ('supplement S2 [p. 24], via open-access author manuscript') and the never-named page 5 fallback, so the tests are not misdescribing the code. The effect is to tighten §3.8 exact provenance: split parts no longer inherit locator words naming a component they do not quote, which removes a real misprovenance rather than loosening a check. The DECISIONS.md line is appended, dated, and stamped with its channel ('founder (direction in session, 2026-09-17)'), consistent with §3.15's treatment of founder directions as the operating record. The only quibble is the code comment saying a marker's parenthetical 'goes with it, as before' when in fact the parenthetical is dropped even for the kept page — a wording imprecision, not a rule breach. The referenced correction to AMZ-E074 is stated to live on another branch and is not part of this diff, so nothing here publishes an unverified locator.
GPT-5.6 Sol (OpenAI)compliescites §3.8, §3.14, §3.15, §8read reasoning
The change tightens locator handling by removing an unquoted place together with its associated wording, while retaining the selected page’s wording and locator-wide provenance such as the copy read or table. The added tests cover both relevant Amazon pages, an alternate separator, and the fallback where the caller supplies a page absent from the parent locator; that fallback formats the explicit page argument rather than inventing an internally chosen locator. The decision entry is append-only and records the review note, rationale, date, and supervision channel. No content citations are added, AGENTS.md is untouched, and the diff strengthens rather than weakens the exact-provenance check.
Gemini 3.8 Flash (Google)compliescites §3.8read reasoning
The change refines `narrowLocator` in `src/domain/proseRefs.ts` to properly associate locator context (such as 'supplement S2') with its specific page marker, resolving review note #341. Previously, dropping an irrelevant page marker left orphan descriptors attached to unrelated pages. This improves adherence to §3.8 (exact provenance) by ensuring that narrowed locators for split parts accurately describe only the cited section.
Grok 4.5 (xAI)compliesread reasoning
The diff only fixes narrowLocator so multi-place parent locators drop whole places (marker plus belonging words) instead of stripping markers and leaving orphan words, which improves exact provenance honesty for split parts. Tests cover the Amazon-style locator, & separators, and an unnamed page; DECISIONS.md records the review-note fix with founder supervision. No AGENTS.md edit, no content citations, no confidence material, no check-weakening, and no run/assessment fabrication.
GLM 5.3 Flash (Z.ai, via Venice)compliescites §3.8, §3.15, §4read reasoning
This is a provenance-accuracy fix, not a check-weakening: the old narrowLocator produced a misleading locator ('[p. 4], supplement S2 via …') that named a supplement the part never quotes, which is exactly the kind of imprecise locator §3.8 forbids; the new place-based narrowing keeps words with their markers and drops whole places, moving toward exact provenance. No AGENTS.md content is edited (only docs/DECISIONS.md, src/domain/proseRefs.{ts,test.ts}), no citations are added (verification found none), no confidence material appears, and the run carries no records needing ratification since it is a mechanical transformation with tests. The new logic's test cases check out against the implementation (kept place retains its words, dropped places go whole, an unnamed page gets only the rest, e.g. 'Table 3', not another place's component). The DECISIONS.md entry honestly attributes the review note and records the founder supervision with date and channel as §3.15 permits, and the AMZ-E074 correction is candidly stated as living on the sitting's branch (#340), not claimed as done here.
judged against constitution dea8581e25 · panel-v3 · verbatim record · pull request