5 of 5 seats affirm compliance; no seat finds a violation
Opus 5 (Anthropic)compliesread reasoning
This is a presentation/domain-layer change: `evidenceTombstones` is the strict complement of `liveEvidence` (rejected records only), and the ledger page now renders refused records in a collapsed section so that `#evidence-<id>` anchors referenced by the case page and history resolve. No content records, citations, or locators are added — the verification section confirms no identifiers in added content lines, and the only fixture id (GEO-E902, dated 2099) lives in a unit test, clearly synthetic and not on the ledger. Nothing about weight or counts changes: `liveEvidence` is untouched and the section label states plainly that tombstones carry no weight and are counted nowhere, so no check in §3.15 is loosened. The tombstone shows the struck title, the source statement, and the refusal text as the record carries it, which supports §3.11 (keeping unfavorable/refused material visible) and §3.14 (history that names an id still resolves). AGENTS.md is not edited; the DECISIONS.md entry is a dated, channel-stamped founder-supervised note consistent with §3.15. Only minor nit: the `refusal()` fallback to the last limitation could surface a non-refusal line as if it were the reason, but limitations are the record's own text and are not misattributed, so this is ordinary imperfection rather than a provenance violation.
GPT-5.6 Sol (OpenAI)compliescites §3.5, §3.8, §3.9, §3.14, §3.15read reasoning
The change preserves rejected evidence as clearly marked tombstones rather than restoring it to the live evidence set, and explicitly states that such records carry no weight and are counted nowhere. It retains the record ID, prior direction, claim links, source statement, and recorded refusal limitation, supporting inspectable provenance and revision history without presenting the record as admitted evidence. The partition test confirms that rejected records remain excluded from `liveEvidence`, while the added anchors repair the link audit rather than weakening or bypassing it. No citations or confidential material are added, and no constitution or epistemic check is modified.
Gemini 3.8 Flash (Google)compliescites §3.8, §3.14, §3.15read reasoning
The PR addresses broken `#evidence-<id>` anchor links by rendering rejected evidence as tombstones in a dedicated section on the ledger page without altering live evidence weighting or counts. This preserves historical provenance and linkability for records referenced in revision histories while explicitly displaying their refused status and rationale (§3.8, §3.14). The change includes unit tests verifying the strict partition between live evidence and tombstones in `src/domain/load.ts`. The founder's direction given in session is duly documented in `docs/DECISIONS.md` in accordance with §3.15. No constitution files are modified and no citations are fabricated.
Grok 4.5 (xAI)compliesread reasoning
The diff only adds UI and a domain helper so refused (reviewState rejected) evidence keeps its #evidence-<id> anchors on the ledger page as closed tombstones—id, former direction/claims, struck title/statement, and the refusal from limitations—without changing liveEvidence weight or counts. No AGENTS.md edit, no citations or content records fabricated, no confidence material, and DECISIONS.md records the founder-directed fix. Matches existing claim-tombstone practice and §3.11/§3.14 transparency.
GLM 5.3 Flash (Z.ai, via Venice)compliescites §3.5, §3.8, §3.11, §3.14, §3.15read reasoning
This is a presentation-layer fix that increases transparency rather than weakening any check: refused evidence records keep their anchors on the ledger page, rendered struck-through in a closed section with the refusal reason the record itself carries, and `liveEvidence`/`verifiedEvidence` are untouched so refused records gain no weight, count nowhere, and cannot be selected as strongest evidence — consistent with §3.11 (refusals recorded), §3.14 (append-only history visible), and the tombstone pattern already used for rejected claims. No citation identifiers are added, so §3.7/§3.8 fabrication concerns do not arise; the test's '2099-01-02' is plainly a synthetic fixture, not a fabricated locator. The diff does not touch AGENTS.md, and the change does not reclassify or dodge any gate — it makes the post-build link audit pass by rendering the anchors the audit correctly demanded. The DECISIONS.md entry attributes the direction to a founder session of 2026-09-17; I cannot verify that session from what I was shown, but I have no positive evidence of misattribution, and such supervision stamps are the repo's established record pattern. Note for the operator (non-blocking): the tombstone UI displays a refused record's sourceStatement even though the record was refused — worth confirming that refused-after-entry records never carried confidence-restricted material, though nothing here suggests they did.
judged against constitution 016a32ae59 · panel-v3 · verbatim record · pull request