5 of 5 seats affirm compliance; no seat finds a violation
Opus 5 (Anthropic)compliesread reasoning
The diff touches only protocols, pipeline code, tests, and the decisions log; AGENTS.md is untouched, and no content/ records or citations are added (the verification section finds no identifiers). The substantive changes tighten rather than loosen the §3.15 checks: verify-v7 adds an `ofTheCompound` question so a split part that states something the compound never bundled is refused, and the implementation fails closed — `if (v2.ofTheCompound !== true)` refuses on false, null, or a missing answer, for both evidence and claim parts, with the reason recorded in the run account. The locator change addresses a §3.8 hazard (a compound's two-place locator passing to a part quoted in only one place) by composing the splitter's own verified-quote locator with the compound's document identity, only when the part's quote is found verbatim in the retrieved text, and leaving the compound's locator untouched when the splitter did not place the part — no locator is invented. Provenance is stamped honestly: the act carries the splitter's model, runId, protocol version (split-v5) and date rather than the reader's, with the reason stating that the second reader judged the placed locator, matching the existing pattern of mechanically-attributed acts in the same array. Version bumps from verify-v6 to verify-v7 in the stamp strings are reflected consistently across chain.test.ts, and the old protocols are archived rather than deleted, preserving history. The DECISIONS.md entry describes the correction and is stamped with founder direction, date and channel as §3.15 permits for operating-record directions.
GPT-5.6 Sol (OpenAI)compliescites §3.2, §3.8, §3.14, §3.15read reasoning
The change strengthens atomicity and lineage checks by requiring every split part to be affirmed as a proposition contained in the original compound, with false, null, or missing answers refused fail-closed. Evidence parts may receive a quote-specific locator, but only when the quote is mechanically present, and the adversarial reader must then approve that placed locator; the change also records the splitter model, run, protocol, date, and reason for the locator act. Tests cover both evidence and claim refusals, missing answers, locator placement, and protocol-version provenance. No citations or content records are added, no files are omitted, AGENTS.md is untouched, and the prior protocols are preserved in the archive rather than silently rewritten.
Gemini 3.8 Flash (Google)compliescites §3.2, §3.8read reasoning
The proposed change strengthens the mechanical verification and split pipelines without touching AGENTS.md or loosening existing gates. It directly reinforces §3.2 (atomic claims) by requiring the verifier to affirm via `ofTheCompound` that split parts are strictly entailed propositions of the compound rather than drifting into neighboring statements, failing closed on false or missing values. It also reinforces §3.8 (exact provenance) by ensuring split evidence parts are located specifically where their own quotes appear rather than inheriting composite multi-place locators from the compound. Full test coverage is included in `src/domain/answer.test.ts` and `src/domain/chain.test.ts`, and all protocol increments are documented honestly in `docs/DECISIONS.md`.
Grok 4.5 (xAI)compliesread reasoning
The diff strengthens split/verify against the exact failure modes named in the body (parts drifting outside the compound; multi-place locators inherited by single-quote parts) without touching AGENTS.md, content records, or citations. split-v5 and verify-v7 keep parts entailed by the compound only, fail-closed on ofTheCompound null/false/absent, and stamp exactLocator placement as the splitter’s act with protocol/model/run/date while the reader still judges locatorSupported. Prior protocol files are archived, DECISIONS.md records a founder session direction, and tests lock the new gates; no fabrication, confidence exposure, or check-weakening is present.
GLM 5.3 Flash (Z.ai, via Venice)compliescites §3.2, §3.8, §3.14, §3.15, §4read reasoning
This change strengthens the §3 checks rather than weakening them: it closes the exact drift the GPT seat's fabrication objection exposed on #372 (parts that were not propositions of the compound, and a locator contradicted by its own quote) by adding a fail-closed `ofTheCompound` gate in verify-v7 and a split-v5 rule that parts together must be the statement and nothing more — a null or missing reader answer refuses the part. Provenance is handled honestly: the locator placement is stamped as the splitter's act with the splitter's model, run, and protocol version (split-v5), not misattributed to the verifier, and the second reader's judgment of the placed locator remains its own; the DECISIONS.md entry records the correction on the record with the founder's in-session supervision noted per §3.15. No AGENTS.md edit occurs, no citations are added (verification section confirms none), prior protocols are archived rather than deleted so history stays inspectable, and tests cover each new rule including the fail-closed null/absent path. Nothing in the diff fabricates a citation, locator, or provenance detail, and nothing dodges or loosens the checks in §3.15.
judged against constitution 1673e88d0c · panel-v3 · verbatim record · pull request